I would think that if the radiator made contact with the road, it would surely crack - even with any of the available guards installed. Some frame sliders or crash guard would be money better spent IMHO. Now as far as looks are concerned, I definitely like some of what I have seen... the rally guards would look awesome powder-coated gloss black. But I'm waiting for some nice carbon-fiber guards to match a few other parts I have planned to pickup.They are very good quality and very thick. The limiting factor being they are fastened with the same thread bolts that hold the original plastic ones on with. In my opinion they would slide well instead of getting ripped off straight away depending on circumstances of course. I also bagged the stainless radiator and oil cooler guards as well. Now they will protect considering the radiator is so exposed. There is a thread within the Scout section on the other Indian forum depicting how beat up the radiators get on normal roads.